Moe:
I think you may be overthinking those later symphonies. I love Mahler to bits. I love Brukner. Never quite warmed up to the symnponies of Brahms, love his chamber stuff. I'm a big Mendelsohn fan. I love Franky Schubert. I pretty much all of it with a few isolated exceptions. I think you make a very good point. Big symphonies do not sound good on cd's. The sound becomes constipated mush. Lp's work though. Mozart is very big in my house. One night Spike came in after a long day at the forge and crashed on the couch. I put on some Mozart string quartets and he said, "Ahhh, the sound of the cabin." Mozart is special here.
I am now into the second cd of the Bernstein St. Mathew Passion. I've been playing it since I got it yesterday. I am starting to really enjoy it. "Verily I say to you,,,,,,"
People don't say verily things anymore.
There is also a quite long lecture by Berntein on the Passion at the end of the cd. It's mostly slightly over my head but I'll struggle along with it. He is Lenny afterall.